Welcome to our best screw extractor set article!
When you apply a greater tear stress than what is required to remove a screw, it’s very common to break the screw. But the trouble comes when you try to remove the broken screw. The size and shape of screws are such that you can never remove them easily. In that case, a screw extractor will help you!
So, you need to understand the details of this useful tool. Below, you’ll find a list of recommendations, ideas, and suggestions about a nice collection of various types of extractors.
Let’s get started.
Our Top Picks
IRWIN Screw Extractor
Alden Grabit Pro
Best Screw Extractor Reviews in 2020
1. IRWIN Tools Hanson Spiral Extractor and Drill Bit Set
The IRWIN HANSON Spiral Extractor and Drill Set is a standard quality drill and extractor set with ten pieces and a case.
The pieces in this box all have a spiraled fluted shape for extra drilling power and better gripping capabilities. The set is made of metal, which makes it strong and durable. This extractor and drill set is surely the top-rated screw extractor available in the market nowadays. Scroll down and read its specifications to learn why it is the best!
Left hand fluted design
The extractor heads come with an advanced left hand fluted design for extra power and strong gripping capabilities. The helical spirals are left handed to assure extra smoothness in gripping. You can use the extractor aggressively and it will still give a better grip and better results than many other screw extractors.
Variety of sizes
The extractors come in different sizes and shapes for different purposes. The extractors sizes are marked on the box so it is easy to find the right one. The extractors are sharp and make drilling out the screws easy.
Bites into screws
The spiral structure of the extractors also gives them extra torque, helping them turn faster and drill into screws evenly. The screws come out smoothly.
- Set of extractors and drill bits
- Spiral shaped extractors for better gripping
- More torque
- Smooth finish
- Sizes embedded on each of the extractors so it’s easy to find the right one
- Works less easily on stainless steel
- Following the instructions is tough for beginners
2. Alden 8440P Pro Grabit Broken Bolt and Damaged Screw Extractor 4 Piece Kit
The Alden 8440P Pro Grabit Broken Bolt and Damaged Screw Extractor is two step drill-powered screw extractor using modern technology. Additional tools of different sizes are not required when you use this extractor. It has an advanced drilling system to get out any type of screw using only one size of extractor.
The extractor features a two-step drilling system for any type and size of screw. The front edge of the extractor is sharpened smoothly to drill a hole into any type of rigid or rusty screw. This set removes screws quickly and with little effort.
No other extractors needed
The best feature of this extractor is that it does not require additional extractor bits. One extractor is enough to handle all types and sizes of bolts and screws out there. The shape and size of the extractors is perfect to remove all screws and bolts.
The extractors are tempered twice during production and have been tested in all weather conditions for better endurance and hardness. Their smooth surfaces have enough torque power to drill out any type of rugged screws or bolts.
- No additional tools required
- Tempered twice for better endurance and hardness
- Tested for durability
- Fast and quick work removing screws and bolts
- Can be brittle and prone to breaking
- Not good for stainless steel
3. IRWIN Tools Power-Grip Screw and Bolt Extractor Set, 7-Piece
If you are like to do your own mechanical work, you need to have the right tools, and this tool is essential. This is the best bolt extractor. It has a reverse spiral flute design that produces a high amount of gripping power.
The product is made of high-carbon steel. The high-carbon steel gives these screw extractors longer life and increased durability.
Universal fitted shank
The IRWIN HANSON POWER-GRIP screw extractor set has a very useful hex shank. This hex shank fits most drills and lets you a change adapters quickly.
The popular high-carbon steel construction gives these screw and bolt extractors longer life and increased durability.
Plastic storage case
This set of bolt extractors comes in a convenient plastic storage case. The case will protect the extractors, and makes it easy to find them—they won’t get lost among the other tools in your toolbox.
Strong gripping power
Its reverse spiral flutes bite down to provide a high amount of gripping power, grabbing a hold of the damaged screw or bolt and powering it out.
Can used with power tools
The 1/4″ hex shank is designed for use with various power drills.
- High carbon steel is very durable
- The plastic case protects the tools and makes it easy to find them in your toolbox
- Fits any bolt size
- The product weighs a little heavier than some other extractors
4. American Tool 8Pc Screw Extractor Set
Along with extreme durability, this one is a great set for effortless screw extraction. It is a good screw extractor set.
Highly durable carbon steel
This high quality extracting set comes with pretty durable and sturdy steel removers. Needless to say, all8 pieces of extractors are made with high carbon steel. The carbon steel frame can take a much better working stress and thus provides you sufficient screw removal service. Again, carbon steel prevents corrosion and hence, making all 8 extractors lasting long enough to work with.
Includes 8 screw removers
This set offers you a complete set of 8 screw extractors to give you maximum control and torque when removing a wide range of screws. With diameters of 5/32″, 5/16″, 1/4″, 9/32″, 7/16″, 5/8″,¾” as well as 15/16″, you can remove all the common sizes of screws.
Great tool for home and garage usage
The combination of greater durability along with a much better range of sizes makes this tool set just perfect to work with. Again, you can remove stripped screws and bolts without any trouble. All the extractors are hard enough to take the stress of removing screws from a car or any other another application.
- Highly polished to cut through drilling surfaces easily
- Simple to use on stripped screws or bolts
- Convenient plastic storage box hold and protects the extractors.
- May require further attempts to remove class A screws.
- May not work well for hard and rust screws.
5. Moody Tools 58-0670 6-Piece Slot/Phil/Screw
Being an extractor and repairing set at the same time, this is the best screw extractor for small screws. It includes an assortment of miniature screwdrivers and screw extractors to repair small components and remove broken or stripped screws.
Durable with hardened blade of steel
This great extracting tool is made with a hardened blade made with high steel. In fact, the firm and hardened steel make the screw extractor pretty tough. Again, this durable and sturdy steel comes with anodized aluminum handles. Thus it provides extra ease of use for you to work with. With greater hardness along with durability, you can take care of any screws in your home.
Repair electronics and extracts screws
In addition to extracting unnecessary, damaged and stripped screws, you can also repair smaller electronic components using these tools. This handy tool set is perfect for smaller screws.
Greater functionality with double-ended reversible blade
All 6 tools come with a double end, adding to their usefulness. And again, these tools have a reversible facility which enables you to effortlessly extract screws. Apart from that, these double-ended blades offer you Phillips and slot styles as well as different sizes, and each tool has a different style or size at each end. Needless to say, these features ensure you will have the right screw extraction tool for the job.
- Comes with interchangeable aluminum handles
- Can be used to repair miniature and small electronics
- Includes pocket clip, knurled grip, and hex-shaped swivel top
- Includes different styles with double-ended blades
- Easy storage and portability with the included
- Not suitable for the largest stripped or broken screws
6. Craftsman 9-66196 Screw Extractor Set, 10 Piece
When you need to fix a lot of screws for large jobs, you need to have tools that let you do the job efficiently and without a hassle. And with this screw extractor set, you get 10 extractors that can handle a variety of sizes with.
Sturdy extractor with heat treated steel
This screw extracting tool offers you one sturdy and durable extracting structure as well. As a matter of fact, the steel to make this great tool is heat treated to make it more effective. Also, the extractor steel is made with black oxide, titanium, and cobalt materials and is strong enough to remove hard and stripped screws.
Includes 5 extractors
All the screws used in your house aren’t the same size. And to take care of unwanted screws and bolts of different sizes, you must have an extractor tool that allows you to work with various screw sizes. In fact, this set has 5 different pieces numbered from 1 to 5. Along with these extracting pieces, you will get 5 HSS drill bits of 5/64”, 7/64”, 5/32”, ¼” and 17/64”. match.
Spiral fluting for better screw extraction
All the extractors, as well as the HSS drill bits, come with spiral flutes to provide greater extracting ability with less effort. In other words, the spiral flutes of the extractors provide an opportunity to remove screw with ease.
- Made of high-quality steel with black oxide, titanium, and cobalt.
- Heat-treated to improve durability
- Offers firm screw installation with 5 spiral HSS drill bits
- May get broken when removing hard screws.
- Drill bits may be a bit too larger to install smaller screws
7. Aisxle Damaged Screw Extractor & Bolt Extractor Set
This best damaged screw extractor set is the ideal everyday tool for any type of damaged screw and bolt extraction. This set with a wide variety of size options.
The extra hardened metal body of the extractor can remove any type of bolt, no matter how long they have been hanging in the wall. The toolbox contains some size options for different sizes of bolts.
The extractor head is made with extra hardened steel for durability. The metal is double coated and was tested in several weather conditions for better performance. The tool was tampered several times as hardening test so that it can deliver better durability and strength.
The extractor head comes in four different sizes for individual purposes. There are many sizes and types of nuts out there. Moreover, nuts change shape if hanged for a long time. But with all of these four individual extractor heads, you can take out any type of nuts. It doesn’t matter how long it had been hanging around.
Easy to use
The extractor tool brings ease to your daily work. This set lets you choose the right shape and size to quickly to remove any type of bolt or screw.
- Extra hardened and stainless steel
- Steel tempered twice for better durability and performance
- Comes with four sizes of extractor heads
- Comes with a lifetime guarantee
- Makes a hole in the wall
8. Rioa Damaged Screw Remover and Bolt Extractor Set
If you are looking forward to getting one best screw extractor, you may check out this one. With a great range of workability over almost all common sized screws, you will get an effective screw removal through this set.
Sturdy frame with hardened steel
This screw extracting tool has a very sturdy and stable structure. As a matter of fact, the steel of this great tool is none other than H.S.S. #4341, which wears well under heavy use.
Effective extracting with 4 tools
The screws used in your house aren’t the same size. To deal with unwanted screws and bolts of different sizes, you will need tools that allow you to work with various screw sizes.
In fact, this tool provides you with 4 screw removal tools for 3-5mm, 4-8mm, 5-10mm and 6-12mm diameter, so you can extract almost all unnecessary screws from your belongings.
- Excellent durability with HSS #4341 hardened steel
- Simple and easy to use on screws and bolts
- Needs a much less time to extract screws
- Works good for free-spinning screws
- May not be suitable for all types of screws and bolts
- May require longer to remove rusty screws
9. Screw Extractor Set – For Removing Stripped Screws And bolts
The Screw Extractor Set – For Removing Stripped Screws and Bolts is a classic looking extractor set made with the latest technology. The set also features a stylish carrier which is made with hardened steel.
Simple two steps drilling system for fast and easy access. User safety assured with extra safety handle at the front. Stability is provided through the front handle. Smart gripping system. Through overall analysis it can be easily said that this is the winner with a classic look. Look down and read the specifications and features to know why this one is the best.
The steel used in making the extractors are hardened through countless tests and processes. The steel is hardened through stainless hardening process. The steel extractors are tampered several times to achieve the highest amount of hardened steel.
The drilling function of the extractors works in two steps. This is the simplest process of all. It saves time and takes less effort. You just need to hold the device in your hand steadily and let the drills do the work.
The frontal handle of the drill provides better stability and strengthens the drilling capabilities. The extractor pieces are smooth enough to stay at their place all the way. The sharpened feature of the pieces allows sharp drilling and accurate cut pieces.
- Durable materials used to last longer
- Extra hardened for better performance
- Two steps drilling system
- Attractive case provided with the case
- Removes screws and bolts faster
- Total drill is large in size
- Multiple extractors are tough to remember perfectly
- Need body muscles to perfectly control the machine
10. Damaged Screw Remover and Extractor Set
The Damaged Screw Remover and Extractor Set is a specially designed extractor set with high quality materials and strong build. The extractor set comes with a guarantee of removing your rusty, rigid old screws and bolts.
The extractor set has 4 individual pieces. All of these pieces were built with the best material in the market. The finish of the pieces is smooth and perfect. You have to use it to know how amazing the torque of this extractor is. Keep reading to know all about this amazing product!
The extractor company emphasizes mostly on the quality of their product. The extractor pieces were made from highest quality materials out there in the market. Stainless steel was used to harden the extractors. The grip and the handle were also made of high quality materials extracted from the best fields.
The full body of the extractor pieces was made from hardened stainless steel. The steel was tampered twice for better durability and stronger performance. The steels were tested to withstand all type of weather conditions. The steel is rust and corrosion free.
The extractor pieces feature easy removal system for the screws and bolts. The front part is smooth and strong enough to bring out any type of rusty, rigid old piece of screw or bolt. It won’t damage your wall in any manner.
- High quality materials used
- Extra hardened stainless steel
- Tampered several times for hardness
- Ease in access
- Easy and fast removal system
- A little strength required to make it perform perfectly
- Instructions are to be properly followed
- Drilling can’t take place if not properly kept at place
Best Screw Extractor Buying Guide
Hardness and durability
If the tools are not hard and durable, they won’t last and may even break when used. Get a strong, well-made, high quality set of screw and bolt extractors.
Quick extracting ability
Quick extracting ability is ensured by the additional pressure exerted by the extractor. This additional pressure is ensured by the spring joined to the handle of the extractor. The stronger the spring, the more powerful the extracting power.
Apparently, all the extractors aren’t suitable for all types of screws. You can’t use a large extractor for extracting your eye glass screw; you need a range of sizes. So, I’ve collected a good variety of extractors to fulfill all of your needs.
Types of Screw Extractor
Left-handed spiral fluted extractor
Most extractors are left-handed. They are used for removing right-handed screws. These are made of hard steel and come in different sizes for different screws. For example, the #7 straight extractor can remove a 7/8″ screw.
Right-handed spiral fluted extractor
This is a coarsely-tapered screw thread like the left-handed tool. Its various size is also available for various purpose. The difference is that it is made for removing the left-handed screw. The wedge action of these extractors weakens the screw.
Micro spiral extractor
This smaller screw extractor is used for more precise extracting, especially for electronic and medical tools as well as precision equipment. As it is used in small and sensitive instruments, these tools are generally made of hardened, high-quality metals. It is the perfect screw extractor for small screws.
Straight fluted extractor
This is another type of wrenched action screw extractor. But it has less wedging effect than the other spiral fluted extractors. It has less of a tendency to lock the screw into place, due to its shape. It is also made with hard materials to bear the brunt of hammering. There are also a variety of available in the market.
Parallel fluted extractor
This tool is not tapered and thus has no wedging. To work well with it you have to drill the pilot hole precisely. And for making standard size drill holes, a drill bit is provided.
Mini straight fluted extractor
Suitable for screw sizes #6-10, these are usually made of hardened hexagonal steel designed. Its shaft is short in length compared to other fluted extractors.
Popular Screw Extractor Brands
On this list, first is the name of Irwin Hanson as it’s a great brand that maintains a premium quality in their screw extractors. In every year’s best extractor reviews, at least two extractors from this brand are included. You can also buy their great metal drill bits and drill bit sharpener.
After Irwin Hanson, my next favorite brand is Moody Tools. It’s an American company known especially for screw extractors and makes almost all types of screw extractors. Almost all of the extractors are hard, durable and easy to use.
This is another renowned brand which mainly makes extractor sets. Their tools include a rich collection of almost all types of extractors. The quality of their extractors is very good. They also produce some top quality tile drill bits and glass drill bits.
Craftsman offers a nice set of extractors and drill bits. They ensure a high standard of quality in their tools. The set includes extractors of different varieties and sizes.
How to Remove Stripped Screw
One of the major challenges of working with metals and screws is the tendency of screws to get stuck. This can happen in our smart phones, electronics, kitchen appliances, our garage and so on. There is no hard and soft rule for removing screws, so in this piece I will discuss various proven strategies.
Using a Rubber Band
In this method, you are expected to put a rubber band over the screw head and firmly tie it in position. Then, you place your screwdriver over the head of the screw (which now has a rubber band on it). Apply a little force and turn the screwdriver gently to unscrew.
The Hammer Method
In this removal process, you will require a hammer. All you need do is to place the screwdriver on top of the stripped screw. You then hit the head of the screwdriver from the top. This is to force the screwdriver to enter the soft metal where the screw is stuck, so you can remove it with the extractor.
Use Epoxy Glue
This will require you to glue a nut on the screw head. Any good epoxy glue can be used forthis. After applying the glue, you leave it to dry and set. When it’s dry, use a wrench and hit the nut to loosen it, helping you to unscrew the stripped screw.
The best stripped screw extractor is a special tool made to remove stuck and stripped screws. they include left twist, fluted bits, reverse bits, and come in a wide variety of sizes.
Drilling a Hole in the Screw
To use this method, you will need a drill bit with a head that is smaller than the stripped screw’s head. Then you drill a hole into the screw. This is to enable you go deep enough so as to be able to unscrew it.
This requires you to use a bigger screwdriver than the screw that is stripped. It is advisable to use the same type of screwdriver, such as slot or Phillips. The idea is to give you a better and firmer grip to be able to unscrew it.
Using a Manual Screwdriver
Use the largest manual screwdriver which fits your screw to remove the screw. It works by gripping the screw head. You can also use penetrating oil if the screw is fastened to metal. If necessary, use a wrench on the screwdriver’s handle to get more leverage.
Add Material for Better Grip
If you want more grip, or if the screwdriver still keeps slipping out of the stripped hole you can use extra material. It could be abrasive or gripping material such as a small piece of rubber band, apiece of steel wool, a duct tape with adhesive side, apiece of abrasive kitchen sponge, etc. Keep this material against the screw head, press the extra material into the hole with the screwdriver, and try again.
As you rotate the screwdriver press down into the screw with your forearm. Stop immediately if the tool is still slipping because continuous slippage will wear down the screw head and make it harder to remove. Be careful to use the correction direction for removal as it is not always counterclockwise.
This involves grabbing the stripped screw with pliers and turning it to remove the screw. This could be the best method of extracting small screws if the head of the screw is above the surface and can be gripped by the pliers.
This method uses a grinder to cut into the screw head. It works easiest if you can get to the notch of the screw. Any brand of grinder can be used, including Ryobi or Dremel.
With a welding tool, you heat up the screw for a moment. This softens the screw, making it easier for you to easily unscrew. You must understand how to use welding equipment, wear the proper safety gear including gloves and a face shield, and be sure that it will not destroy the surface in which the screw is embedded.
Drilling the Head Off
All you need to do is to drill into the screw head. The drill bit must be smaller than the shaft of the screw to avoid destroying the thread. When the head is removed the shaft will soften, making it easier for you to grab it with pliers and unscrew the screw.
This works best using a Phllips screw head. You will use the flat screwdriver, push hard on the screw head, and attempt to turn or unscrew it. This option is easy due to the good grip that is associated with flat faced screwdrivers. Interestingly, this can be combined with the first option of using a rubber band.
Heat the Area Around the Screw
You can even try heating the screw. This technique is especially helpful when the screw has been set in place with a bonding agent. But you need to be careful and avoid overheating, as this may cause damage to the object the screw is embedded in. A heat gun or propane torch is best for this purpose.
Tap the Screwdriver
Tap on the head of the screw with a hammer to avoid slippage. Tap gently to avoid damage. Skip this step if the screw is in a fragile object.
Cut a Flat Head Notch Using a Hacksaw
Cut a notch into the screw head if your screwdriver can’t still get a good grip. You can also use a Dremel to cut a flat-head notch.
How To Remove a Screw with no Head
First we dealt with a stripped screw with the head still in place. Next, we offer suggestions for removing a stripped screw without a screw head. This means that the head has fallen off, maybe in the process of trying to unscrew it, or it broke off. What you have left is a shaft that is inside the device and must be removed.
Use a Screw Extractor
If a stripped screw does not have a head, it is almost impossible to remove it without having this tool. This tool comes in various sizes and can work equally well to remove bolts. Screw extractors can include the following parts.
Square Head: This is fastened to another device called a T- handle. The head can also be used on the screw directly and turned using an adjustable wrench.
Shaft: This is the connection between the head and the tapered cutting screw.
Reverse Tapered Cutting Screw Threads: This is the major part of the tool. It is tapered to bore into the screw in an anti-clockwise direction. This goes deep enough to grip the damaged screw and then makes it easy to pull out or remove the screw.
Create a Temporary Head for Gripping
If you are facing problems without the screw head, there is a solution for you. Heat a flat screwdriver and push it onto the top of the screw, leaving a slot, square or cross on the screw. Apply the process several times, and it will create a grip on the top of the screw. Then you can use other tools to remove the screw.
Using a Drill Bit
This tool is used to prepare the damaged screw to receive the screw extractor. One must ensure that it does not drill to the point of breaking off the shaft or damage the drill. The drill bit’s diameter must be small enough to simply to drill a hole for the extractor to fit into.
The extractor can be used with a hammer in the cases when it is difficult to simply turn the T-handle. This, of course, needs to be done gently to fit, after which the screw can be pulled out.
Heat the Screw and the Surrounding Material
Heat the area using a heat gun or propane torch and let it cool for fifteen minutes. Apply thise process several times. These will cause an enlargement of the screw pocket and help you to remove the screw. Move the torch constantly to avoid overheating that may harm the screw pocket.
Hammer on the Opposite Side
If possible, tap the object on the opposite side of the screw head. Hit it gently so the object will not be damaged. You should skip this process if you can use other methods.
Apply Penetrating Oil
You can use a penetrating oil such as WD40 if the screw is fastened in a metal surface. The oil will allow the screw to move more smoothly in the screw pocket and thus help you to remove it.
Frequently Asked Questions(FAQ)
Question: Can I remove a broken eye glass screw by using a screw extractor?
Answer: Yes, of course. You can easily remove it by using a straight flute extractor. Generally, eye glass screws are very small. So, you need small extractors. In addition, you need also use an extractor that is designed for the shape of the screw you will remove.
Question: Will I get a carrying case with screw extractors?
Answer: Usually. Many of the extractors we reviewed have plastic cases some have a clip to attach the extractor to your belt.
Question: Can I get a user manual or guide for using the screw extractor?
Answer: Yes, you’ll get a screw extractor guide. The guide will be included with the extractor and explain all the information you need to use that extractor.
Question: Can I remove irreversible screw by using these extractors?
Answer: Yes, you can do so by using Rioa Damaged screw extractor set.
The above information gives you a complete guide for choosing the best screw extractors. The screw extractors listed above will help you remove a variety of sizes and shapes of screws embedded in a wide range of materials.